After a 10-year fight, the case was determined in favour of the plaintiffs
-- with a majority of six to one. The ruling was a landmark decision as it
effectively nullified the doctrine of terra nullius -- the assumption that
Australia was uninhabited or "empty" at the time of first
European contact and
therefore Crown territory by default. The ruling recognised that
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people may still hold common law
title or native title to land where it has not been lost by valid acts of
government, or the loss of traditional connection with the land.
However the High Court indicated that native title is extinguished by
grants of exclusive possession -- such as freehold and residential leases.
The Native Title Act sought to incorporate the principles of the Mabo case
into Australian land law and management. The aim of the legislation was
two-fold: to preserve the integrity and certainty of Australia's land
management system, and to
provide a measure of justice for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander
people. It was shaped after a long process of discussion and
negotiation with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, State and
Territory governments and mining pastoral and other industry groups.
Wik
It was assumed in the High Court's Mabo decision that native
title extinguished by grants of exclusive possession included pastoral
leases and other non-exclusive tenures. This assumption was carried
through into the Native Title Act. However in 1996, the Wik people of Cape
York brought a case to the High Court, which served to test the validity
of this assumption.
In December 1996, the High Court handed down its decision on Wik, ruling
that native title may survive on pastoral leases, but added that the
rights of pastoral lessees prevail over any rights that native
titleholders may have. The implication of the High Court's Wik ruling was
exposure of a much greater area of Australia over which native title
claims could be made -- without deciding
whether any particular claim would be successful.
The Government believed legislative amendment of the Native Title Act was
essential. On September 4, 1997, the Government introduced the Native
Title Amendment Bill (1997) to deal with the uncertainty arising from the
Wik decision. The Senate passed the Bill on July 8, 1998 after
comprehensive consultation with all stakeholders. The new Native Title Act
may be summarised
by the following features, which incorporate the Government's 10-point
plan: Validation of acts between January 1, 1994 and December
23, 1996 -- ensuring the legal effect of acts or grants made over
non-vacant Crown land between the commencement of the Native Title Act and
the Wik decision.
Confirmation of the common law status of native title -- allowing States
and Territories to confirm the High Court's Wik decision that exclusive
tenures -- such as freehold, residential, commercial and most agricultural
leases, and existing public works -- granted on or before December 23,
1996 extinguished native title.
Confirmation that essential government-type services to the public can be
provided without extinguishing native title -- ensuring native title
holders are entitled to full compensation for any impact on their native
title rights.
Confirmation State and Territory Governments' rights to permit all primary
production activities on pastoral leases, even if native title exists --
allowing pastoralists to manage their properties into the future. If
additional rights are granted, native title will be suppressed -- not
extinguished -- and
native title holders will be entitled to full compensation.
Confirmation of statutory access rights -- allowing registered claimants
who show they had physical access to pastoral lease land on December 23,
1996 for the purpose of carrying out traditional activities to continue to
have access while their native title claim is determined.
Introduction of a higher registration test for claimants seeking the right
to negotiate in light of proposed mining activity and commercial and
government development on vacant Crown land -- ensuring mining companies
and governments will only have to negotiate once with applicants and will
deal only with applicants whose native title claims are likely to succeed.
Introduction of State-based regimes for mining and commercial and
government development on other non-exclusive tenures. Until State-based
regimes are introduced, the statutory right to negotiate will continue to
apply. Confirmation of governments' right to regulate
and manage surface and subsurface water, living aquatic resources and
airspace.
Improvement of management of native title claims
incorporating an acceptance test and registration test for applicants and
State management of claims. Clarification of native title agreements -- the
Act guarantees legal certainty for voluntary agreements about native title.
For more
information on the Aboriginal People of
Australia, go to:
|